Double-Row Capsulolabral Repair Increases Load to Failure and Decreases Excessive Motion

摘要

Purpose: Using a cadaver shoulder instability model and load-testing device, we compared biomechanical characteristics of double-row and single-row capsulolabral repairs. We hypothesized a greater reduction in glenohumeral motion and translation and a higher load to failure in a mattress double-row capsulolabral repair than in a single-row repair. Methods: In 6 matched pairs of cadaveric shoulders, a capsulolabral injury was created. One shoulder was repaired with a single-row technique, and the other with a double-row mattress technique. Rotational range of motion, anterior-inferior translation, and humeral head kinematics were measured. Load-to-failure testing measured stiffness, yield load, deformation at yield load, energy absorbed at yield load, load to failure, deformation at ultimate load, and energy absorbed at ultimate load. Results: Double-row repair significantly decreased external rotation and total range of motion compared with single-row repair. Both repairs decreased anterior-inferior translation compared with the capsulolabral-injured condition, however, no differences existed between repair types. Yield load in the single-row group was 171.3 +/- 110.1 N, and in the double-row group it was 216.1 +/- 83.1 N (P = .02). Ultimate load to failure in the single-row group was 224.5 +/- 121.0 N, and in the double-row group it was 373.9 +/- 172.0 N (P = .05). Energy absorbed at ultimate load in the single-row group was 1,745.4 +/- 1,462.9 N-mm, and in the double-row group it was 4,649.8 +/- 1,930.8 N-mm (P = .02). Conclusions: In cases of capsulolabral disruption, double-row repair techniques may result in decreased shoulder rotational range of motion and improved load-to-failure characteristics. Clinical Relevance: In cases of capsulolabral disruption, repair techniques with double-row mattress repair may provide more secure fixation. Double-row capsulolabral repair decreases shoulder motion and increases load to failure, yield load, and energy absorbed at yield load more than single-row repair.