A comparison between advanced hybrid machine learning algorithms and empirical equations applied to abutment scour depth prediction

摘要

Complex vortex flow patterns around bridge piers, especially during floods, cause scour process that can result in the failure of foundations. Abutment scour is a complex three-dimensional phenomenon that is difficult to predict especially with traditional formulas obtained using empirical approaches such as regressions. This paper presents a test of a standalone Kstar model with five novel hybrid algorithm of bagging (BA-Kstar), dagging (DA-Kstar), random committee (RC-Kstar), random subspace (RS-Kstar), and weighted instance handler wrapper (WIHWKstar) to predict scour depth (ds) for clear water condition. The dataset consists of 99 scour depth data from flume experiments (Dey and Barbhuiya, 2005) using abutment shapes such as vertical, semicircular and 45 degrees wing. Four dimensionless parameter of relative flow depth (h/l), excess abutment Froude number (Fe), relative sediment size (d(50)/l) and relative submergence (d(50)/h) were considered for the prediction of relative scour depth (d(s)/l). A portion of the dataset was used for the calibration (70%), and the remaining used for model validation. Pearson correlation coefficients helped deciding relevance of the input parameters combination and finally four different combinations of input parameters were used. The performance of the models was assessed visually and with quantitative metrics. Overall, the best input combination for vertical abutment shape is the combination of F-e, d(50)/l and h/l, while for semicircular and 45 degrees wing the combination of the Fe and d(50)/l is the most effective input parameter combination. Our results show that incorporating Fe, d(50)/l and h/l lead to higher performance while involving d(50)/h reduced the models prediction power for vertical abutment shape and for semicircular and 45 degrees wing involving h/l and d(50)/h lead to more error. The WIHW-Kstar provided the highest performance in scour depth prediction around vertical abutment shape while RC-Kstar model outperform of other models for scour depth prediction around semicircular and 45 degrees wing.