A comparison of waste leaching determination methods in the context of dewatered oil sands fine tailings

摘要

Leaching tests are an important component in assessing the potential of contaminants to leach from waste materials to the environment. Numerous leaching test protocols have been developed for different applications. In this study, we compare four different methods in the context of assessing leaching of inorganic ions from oil sands tailings. The four methods compared were: United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure; ASTM D6234; ASTM D3987; and what we refer to as the Deionized method (modified from Syncrude Analytical Aqueous Extraction of Oil Sand Method 1.7). It was found that the EPA Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure generally resulted in the highest ion concentrations. The EPA method had statistically different results for three of the four tailings mixes when compared with the other three leaching methods. For Mo and Ti the EPA method always resulted in the lowest concentrations compared with the other methods, and As, Tl, and Pb sometimes resulted in the lowest concentrations. The other three leaching protocols resulted in similar dissolved ion concentrations.