IF THE JURIES HAD BEEN DIFFERENT, THEN SO WOULD SOME OF THE CHOICES

摘要

On this issues letters page (see page 22),John Lyall takes the AJ to task in part for not editing out Alan Dunlop's negative criticism of Penoyre & Prasad's Moorfields Eye Hospital (see the Building Study, AJ 26.04.07). Since it is not Lyall's building, he cannot be accused of sour grapes. Instead, he seems to feel that it is unfair for the architects of a building that he admires to suffer negative comments from their peers which will, in turn, be read by their peers.