Equatorial Forests Display Distinct Trends in Phenological Variation: A Time-Series Analysis of Vegetation Index Data from Three Continents

摘要

Recent studies have questioned the applicability of satellite-derived vegetation indices (VIs) for evaluating phenological variation in tropical forests, due to potential artifacts caused by the bidirectional reflectance distribution function (BRDF). For nadir-normalized data, BRDF will be driven principally by intraannual variation in solar elevation. Where areas lying on the same latitude are under similar solar elevation “regimes,” if the observed variation in VIs is indeed driven by BRDF, then different regions at the same latitude should display identical VI variations. That hypothesis was tested by comparing VI data for tropical evergreen forests in three zones north of the equator (the Guianas, central Africa, and northern Borneo). Enhanced vegetation index, the fraction of green vegetation cover, and leaf area index (LAI) from MODIS and SPOT VEGETATION ultimately showed that VI trends for the regions differ greatly. The trend for Borneo's forests is generally flat over the 12 years studied, while data for the Guianas and central Africa both exhibit strong but distinct seasonal patterns. Correlation analyses indicate that the VI trends between zones are neither strongly correlated to each other nor to variation in solar elevation (except in central Africa), suggesting that the observed variation in the VIs is not driven by BRDF. In contrast, regression analysis indicated that for the Guianas and central Africa, VI variation was most explained by variation in environmental factors, but not atmospheric effects, suggesting seasonally driven phenology.