Early monk seals (Monachinae: Monachini) from the late Miocene-early Pliocene of Australia

摘要

Despite decades of research, the systematics of extinct true seals (Phocidae) is still overly reliant on morphological data from extant taxa. As a result, monk seals (Monachini) have been interpreted as 'archaic' despite an absence of fossil data to support this hypothesis. This has affected systematic hypotheses for extinct phocids, including fossils from Australasia. Recent finds from New Zealand indicate that the first seal fossils described from Australia, two temporal bones from the late Miocene-early Pliocene (6.24-4.35 Ma), need to be revisited. Here we re-describe these temporal bones and find them to represent monk seals. This places the oldest known fossils of this group in the Southern Hemisphere, implying monk seals had a longer history at southern latitudes. Our ancestral state estimation of the temporal bone morphology of monachines indicates that monk seal temporals may be derived, rather than plesiomorphic as has previously been assumed. This suggests that an over-reliance on the morphology of extant true seals may be obscuring the true diversity of both stem- and crown-phocids, and indicates that a rethink of the morphology underlying the taxonomic assessments of fragmentary true seal fossils is needed.