Contemporary China's Rural Landownership with Reference to Antony M. Honore's Concept of Ownership

摘要

This article analyses the property rights that Chinese peasants have under the present Household Responsibility System (HRS) using Antony M. Honore's work on ownership, especially his analysis of eleven standard incidents of the full liberal concept of ownership. It confirms Honore's insight that these standard incidents can be divided among two or more persons, and thus there are different types of property rights which are variants and alternatives to the liberal type of property rights. This article also confirms that the Chinese land system is a real alternative to the full liberal concept of ownership. The current Chinese land system is alleged to be unclear and insecure because it is not the kind of private ownership that neoliberals champion. In the tradition of the bundle of rights theory, it is helpful to use Honore's concept of ownership, rather than Harold Demsetz's type of property rights, to understand the current Chinese system.