Through a glass darkly: Some insights on change talk via magnetoencephalography

摘要

Motivational interviewing (MI) is a directive, client-centered therapeutic method employed in the treatment of substance abuse, with strong evidence of effectiveness. To date, the sole mechanism of action in MI with any consistent empirical support is “change talk” (CT), which is generally defined as client within-session speech in support of a behavior change. “Sustain talk” (ST) incorporates speech in support of the status quo. MI maintains that during treatment, clients essentially talk themselves into change. Multiple studies have now supported this theory, linking within-session speech to substance use outcomes. Although a causal chain has been established linking therapist behavior, client change talk, and substance use outcome, the neural substrate of change talk has been largely uncharted. We addressed this gap by measuring neural responses to clients’ own change talk using magnetoencephalography (MEG), a non-invasive neuroimaging technique with excellent spatial and temporal resolution. Following a recorded MI session, MEG was used to measure brain activity while participants heard multiple repetitions of their CT and ST utterances from that session, intermingled and presented in a random order.Results suggest that CT processing occurs in a right-hemisphere network that includes inferior frontal gyrus, insula, and superior temporal cortex. These results support a representation of change talk at the neural level, consistent with the role of these structures in self-perception. This suggests that during treatment sessions, clinicians who are able to evoke this special kind of language are tapping into neural circuitry that may be essential to behavior change.