In a comment on our article “Theory of Thomson scattering in inhomogeneous media”, V. V. Belyi asserts that there is an inconsistency in our method of applying gradient effects via the dielectric superposition principle, in violation of the fluctuation-dissipation theorem; and that his Klimontovich-Langevin formulation would be more appropriate to our application. While we agree that a generalization, along the lines of Belyi’s work, would be required for strongly coupled systems, for the weakly coupled systems which we considered, these corrections are not necessary and our approach is still appropriate.Replying to: V. Belyi, Sci. Rep. 8 (2018); 10.1038/s41598-018-25319-6.
展开▼
机译：V. V. Belyi在对我们的文章“非均质介质中的Thomson散射理论”的评论中断言，通过介电叠加原理应用梯度效应的方法存在矛盾，这与波动耗散定理相违背；而且他的Klimontovich-Langevin配方更适合我们的应用。尽管我们同意对于强耦合系统需要遵循Belyi的工作进行概括，但对于我们考虑的弱耦合系统，则不需要进行这些更正并且我们的方法仍然适用。科学众议院8（2018）; 10.1038 / s41598-018-25319-6。
展开▼
