Extrinsic visual feedback and additional cognitive/physical demands affect single-limb balance control in individuals with ankle instability

摘要

AIM To investigate the impact of extrinsic visual feedback and additional cognitive/physical demands on single-limb balance in individuals with ankle instability.METHODS Sixteen subjects with ankle instability participated in the study. Ankle instability was identified using the Cumberland Ankle Instability Tool(CAIT). The subject's unstable ankle was examined using the Athletic Single Leg Stability Test of the Biodex Balance System with 4 different protocols:(1) default setting with extrinsic visual feedback from the monitor;(2) no extrinsic visual feedback;(3) no extrinsic visual feedback with cognitive demands; and(4) no extrinsic visual feedback with physical demands. For the protocol with added cognitive demands,subjects were asked to continue subtracting 7 from a given number while performing the same test without extrinsic visual feedback. For the protocol with added physical demands,subjects were asked to pass and catch a basketball to and from the examiner while performing the same modified test. RESULTS The subject's single-limb postural control varied significantly among different testing protocols(F = 103; P = 0.000). Subjects' postural control was the worst with added physical demands and the best with the default condition with extrinsic visual feedback. Pairwisecomparison shows subjects performed significantly worse in all modified protocols(P < 0.01 in all comparisons) compared to the default protocol. Results from all 4 protocols are significantly different from each other(P < 0.01) except for the comparison between the "no extrinsic visual feedback" and "no extrinsic visual feedback with cognitive demands" protocols. Comparing conditions without extrinsic visual feedback,adding a cognitive demand did not significantly compromise single-limb balance control but adding a physical demand did. Scores from the default protocol are significantly correlated with the results from all 3 modified protocols: No extrinsic visual feedback(r = 0.782; P = 0.000); no extrinsic visual feedback with cognitive demands(r = 0.569; P = 0.022); no extrinsic visual feedback with physical demands(r = 0.683; P = 0.004). However,the CAIT score is not significantly correlated with the single-limb balance control from any of the 4 protocols: Default with extrinsic visual feedback(r =-0.210; P = 0.434); no extrinsic visual feedback(r =-0.450; P = 0.081); no extrinsic visual feedback with cognitive demands(r =-0.406; P = 0.118); no extrinsic visual feedback with physical demands(r =-0.351; P = 0.182).CONCLUSION Single-limb balance control is worse without extrinsic visual feedback and/or with cognitive/physical demands. The balance test may not be a valid tool to examine ankle instability.