Microsoft Dynamics NAV is a widely used enterprise resource planning system for small and medium-sized enterprises that, by design, encourages rapid customization by copy-paste programming. We report the results of analyzing clone detection for NAV using two previously published methods and one new algorithmic method: character-based sliding window sampling using Rabin-Karp hashing (MOSS), line-based sequence matching using suffix trees (CodeDup), and abstract-syntax-tree based graph sharing analysis (XMLClone). The latter is piggybacked on XMLStore, which stores XML trees as directed acyclic graphs (dags) where all isomorphic subtrees are identified and coalesced into single nodes, which can be done in linear time using multiset discrimination. This dagification discovers all well-formed Type-1 and, with suitable input normalization, Type-2 clones. We find that the subsequent dag analysis to discover Type-3 clones performs well on NAV source code, both in terms of computational complexity and precision. This suggests that efficient dagification and independently configurable dag interpretation may be valuable ingredients for modular clone detection.
展开▼
