BOOSTED REGRESSION TREES OUTPERFORMS SUPPORT VECTOR MACHINES IN PREDICTING (REGIONAL) YIELDS OFWINTER WHEAT FROM SINGLE AND CUMULATED DEKADAL SPOT-VGT DERIVED NORMALIZED DIFFERENCE VEGETATION INDICES

摘要

This paper compares two machine learning techniques to predict regional winter wheat yields. The models, based on Boosted Regression Trees (BRT) and Support Vector Machines (SVM), are constructed of Normalized Difference Vegetation Indices (NDVI) derived from low resolution SPOT VEGETATION satellite imagery. Three types of NDVI-related predictors were used: Single NDVI, Incremental NDVI and Targeted NDVI.rnBRT and SVM were first used to select features with high relevance for predicting the yield. Although the exact selections differed between the prefectures, certain periods with high influence scores for multiple prefectures could be identified. The same period of high influence stretching from March to June was detected by both machine learning methods. After feature selection, BRT and SVM models were applied to the subset of selected features for actual yield forecasting. Whereas both machine learning methods returned very low prediction errors, BRT seems to slightly but consistently outperform SVM.