首页>
外文OA文献
>How to review journal manuscripts : a lesson learnt from the world's excellent reviewers
【2h】
How to review journal manuscripts : a lesson learnt from the world's excellent reviewers
展开▼
机译:如何审阅期刊手稿:从世界优秀审稿人那里汲取的教训
展开▼
免费
页面导航
摘要
著录项
相似文献
相关主题
摘要
Considering the lack of a common and structured approach to evaluate manuscripts for academic journals, this study examines top-quality reviewers' perceptions of peer review and synthesizes their approaches to produce a reference guide to help reviewers, especially inexperienced scholars, understand the process. Using qualitative data collected from 24 recipients of excellent reviewer awards in tourism, hospitality, social sciences, and management, the findings of this study show that reviewers across different fields commonly regard the peer review process positively as an objective assessment mechanism that can improve the quality of research output. Though it does not identify a single and structured approach to reading and reviewing manuscripts, this study derives 12 "content" and 15 "process" issues considered by top-quality reviewers during the process. It is also shown that excellent reviewers adopt one of three general procedures, namely the content- or process-oriented approach, or a mixture of both, when they review manuscripts.
展开▼