Evaluation of Toledo Edison Company's 316(A) and 316(B) Demonstrations for the Bay Shore Station

摘要

Toledo Edison Company's Bay Shore steam electric generation station in Oregon, Ohio, discharges effluents into nearby Maumee Bay. Demonstration report 316(a) by WAPORA (1977) analyzed the impacts of thermal discharge on Maumee Bay, and demonstration report 316(b) by Reutter et al (1978) analyzed the impact of entrainment and impingement on fish communities. Pacific Northwest Laboratory assessed these two reports. We generally agree with WAPORA (1977) on the impact of thermal effluents on the Maumee Bay ecosystems. Our computations indicated temperature increases which would result in larger areas of isotherms, but these increases were insignificant in terms of the percent of the area of Maumee Bay affected. We basically agree with Reutter et al (1978) conclusions concerning impingement and entrainment losses at Bay Shore Station. Our calculations indicate that the impingement data presented in Reutter et al (1978) are accurate estimates based on their sampling program. Their 95% confidence limits for less frequently caught species of fish, however, are too conservative. (ERA citation 06:017524)