Intercomparison of sampling techniques among five European laboratories for measurements of radiocaesium in upland pasture and soil

摘要

Intercomparison of sampling procedures used by five European laboratories for the determination of radiocesium in vegetation and peaty soil was carried out at two locations in Cumbria. The soil sampling procedures included the collection of depth profiles in order to obtain information on the vertical distribution of radiocesium in addition to the total deposition. The number of samples taken by each laboratory varied from one to five. The multiple sampling has given information on the homogeneity of the parameters studied at each location. The parameters comprise soil bulk densities, total deposition of (sup 137)Cs, deposition of (sup 137)Cs in three soil layers, biomass densities, concentrations of (sup 137)Cs in pasture, and activity ratios ((sup 134)Cs/(sup 137)Cs) in soil and vegetation. The determination of total deposition of (sup 137)Cs gave no indication of differences between the laboratories. The total depositions of (sup 134)Cs and (sup 137)Cs observed at one site were compared with levels obtained from another study and the two sets of data were found to be in good agreement. The results from the soil profiles do indicate significant differences between laboratories. This covers the vertical distributions of (sup 137)Cs deposition including the (sup 134)Cs/(sup 137)Cs-activity ratios as well as the soil bulk densities. One laboratory using a coring technique observed difficulties during sampling due to compression of the soil. The coring technique should thus be avoided or applied with extreme care for the sampling of depth profiles in peaty soil. The results from the sampling of pasture show no indication of differences between the laboratories. For the parameters studied the observed variabilities across soil depths and locations range from 10% to 82% in terms of relative standard deviations. A comparison across all results at the two locations indicate a 50% higher field variability at one of the sites relative to the other. (Atomindex citation 24:005580)