The man swimming against the stream knows the strength of it Hydraulics and social relations in an Argentinean irrigation system

摘要

In this paper we discuss hydraulic behavior of irrigation infrastructure within a context of spatially distributed power relations in an Argentinean irrigation system. In the Rio Dulce basin, the irrigation area known as the Proyecto Rio Dulce (PRD, command area 350,000 hectares) is the main irrigated area. An interesting characteristic of the PRD is that the larger landowners are mainly situated in tail end areas. Despite this potentially disadvantageous position, downstream farmers do not encounter problems in terms of water availability. This should not be regarded as self-evident: the hydraulic properties of the canals induce a need for downstream farmers to take deliberate action to ensure proper water delivery to their farms. When upstream farmers do not irrigate, too much water can flow downstream; when they irrigate too much, or manipulate cross regulators, downstream water scarcity can be the resu when canals are not maintained, extensive plant growth will increase hydraulic resistance and decrease discharges. It is not a coincidence that the downstream farmers invest heavily in canal operation and maintenance. These investments appear to be appropriate, as larger farmers tend to irrigate much more on average, compared to the smaller farmers upstream. The Argentinean case brings up issues on the structuring effects of irrigation systems, which need stronger theoretical understanding.