首页> 外文期刊>Oil and Gas Reporter >Court Jurisdiction, Procedure and Review: Concursus Proceedings
【24h】

Court Jurisdiction, Procedure and Review: Concursus Proceedings

机译:法院管辖权,程序和审查:同意程序

获取原文
获取原文并翻译 | 示例
       

摘要

Following a dispute over royalty payments under a mineral lease, plaintiff invokes a concursus pleading, alleging that there are competing claims to these payments. Plaintiffs' basis for suspending payments is the claim by the Mauboules that a prior lease on their property with Ereunao Oil & Gas included a prescription interruption clause that was inserted fraudulently. The trial and appellate courts find that the plaintiff has no legitimate basis for initiating the concursus, because plaintiff needs to and does not show that the Mauboules made an adverse claim to the royalties. The Court of Appeal, 6 So.3d 399, 170 O.&G.R. 561 (La.App. 2009) states that plaintiffs did not show how the fraud assertions against Ereunao could present a challenge to royalty claims by Orange River, who purchased shares of outstanding mineral royalties from Ereunao. Held: reversed. Concursus is properly invoked in this case. There are competing claims to the same royalty payments. There is no requirement of formality under Article 4652, so the Mauboules' pre-concursus written and verbal assertions of fraud are sufficient to constitute a competing claim. It is not plaintiff's duty to determine the merits of the Mauboules' claims.
机译:在就矿产租赁项下的特许权使用费付款发生争议之后,原告援引了一项同意书,声称对这些付款有相互竞争的要求。原告中止付款的依据是Mauboules声称,他们与Ereunao Oil&Gas的财产先前的租赁中包含了一项以欺诈手段插入的处方中断条款。初审法院和上诉法院认为,原告没有发起提起合并的正当依据,因为原告需要而且没有表明Mauboules对特许权使用费提出了不利要求。上诉法院,6 O.3d 399,170 O.&G.R。 561(La.App。2009)指出,原告并未说明针对Ereunao的欺诈主张如何可能对Orange River提出的权利主张提出挑战,Orange River从Ereunao购买了未偿还的矿产特许权使用费。举行:倒转。在这种情况下,可以适当地调用Concursus。对于相同的特许权使用费,存在相互竞争的主张。根据第4652条,没有形式上的要求,因此Mauboules的事先一致同意的书面和口头欺诈指控足以构成相互竞争的主张。确定Mauboules主张的是非曲直不是原告的责任。

著录项

相似文献

  • 外文文献
  • 中文文献
  • 专利
获取原文

客服邮箱:kefu@zhangqiaokeyan.com

京公网安备:11010802029741号 ICP备案号:京ICP备15016152号-6 六维联合信息科技 (北京) 有限公司©版权所有
  • 客服微信

  • 服务号