A comparative analysis of several vulnerability concepts. (Special Issue: Vulnerability to natural hazards? The challenge of integration.)

摘要

A comparative analysis of six vulnerability models aims to identify differences and similarities between several approaches towards understanding vulnerability. The analysis yields a set of characteristics for explaining the condition of vulnerability (multiple contexts, multiple dimensions, temporal variability, multiple scales and scale-interdependency). In addition, 'adaptation' and 'adaptive capacity' are identified as key elements of vulnerability. The results of the analysis are put into a wider context not only of vulnerability but also of resilience and risk research. It is demonstrated that 'adaptation' and 'adaptive capacity' serve as hinges not only for conceptualising vulnerability but between 'vulnerability' and 'resilience' alike. Based on the results of the comparative analysis, a model of vulnerability focussing on the household and community scale is developed, which displays the key findings of this work.Digital Object Identifier http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11069-011-9823-7