Neuropsychological correlates of learning disabilities: Subtype identification by the tryon clustering method

摘要

Since Samuel Orton's (1937) assertion that dyslexia reflects abnormal brain organization, the relationship of learning disabilities to brain dysfunction has been the topic of considerable debate. Recently, learning-disabled individuals have been studied in conjunction with those known to have neurological dysfunction, in a search for common subtypes. In the present study, a population of 177 children, ages 9-0 to 14-0, were assessed on an augmented version of the Children's Halstead-Reitan Battery. One hundred twenty-nine Ss were learning-disabled, 37 of whom also had verified brain damage. The remaining 48 children had neither learning disabilities nor evidence of brain damage. Patterns of neuropsychological performance were determined using Tryon's clustering methods. The procedure yielded six subject clusters: (A) and (B)—children with low general intellectual ability; (C) children who are clumsy and lethargic; (D) children with language dysfunction; (E) children with faulty spatial orientation; and (F) children with no detectable neuropsychological deficits. These clusters were similar to those identified by investigators who have used other subject-clustering methods. Brain-damaged individuals were more prevalent in some clusters (e.g., A and B) than in others (e.g., E and F), and substantial numbers of learning disabled subjects were also found in clusters where brain-damaged individuals tended to cluster, indicating similar neuropsychological profiles. The cluster structure was validated by comparison with subtypes identified by other investigators, as well as by tests of association between clusters with exogenous factors (e.g., history of prematurity; seizures