Assessing local and spatial uncertainty with nonparametric geostatistics

摘要

Uncertainty quantification is an important topic for many environmental studies, such as identifying zones where potentially toxic materials exist in the soil. In this work, the nonparametric geostatistical framework of histogram via entropy reduction (HER) is adapted to address local and spatial uncertainty in the context of risk of soil contamination. HER works with empirical probability distributions, coupling information theory and probability aggregation methods to estimate conditional distributions, which gives it the flexibility to be tailored for different data and application purposes. To explore how HER can be used for estimating threshold-exceeding probabilities, it is applied to map the risk of soil contamination by lead in the well-known dataset of the region of Swiss Jura. Its results are compared to indicator kriging (IK) and to an ordinary kriging (OK) model available in the literature. For the analyzed dataset, IK and HER predictions achieve the best performance and exhibit comparable accuracy and precision. Compared to IK, advantages of HER for uncertainty estimation in a fine resolution are that it does not require modeling of multiple indicator variograms, correcting order-relation violations, or defining interpolation/extrapolation of distributions. Finally, to avoid the well-known smoothing effect when using point estimations (as is the case with both kriging and HER), and to provide maps that reflect the spatial fluctuation of the observed reality, we demonstrate how HER can be used in combination with sequential simulation to assess spatial uncertainty (uncertainty jointly over several locations).