Comparison of efficacy of aminolaevulinic acid photodynamic therapy vs. adapalene gel plus oral doxycycline for treatment of moderate acne vulgaris-A simple, blind, randomized, and controlled trial

摘要

Background Although progress has been made in the study of photodynamic therapy for acne, studies using current recommended therapies as active comparators are lacking. Methods Randomized, controlled trial involving 46 patients with moderate inflammatory facial acne, 23 patients received two sessions of PDT separated by 2 weeks (ALA 20% incubated 1.5 hours before red light irradiation with 37 J/cm(2) fluence) and 23 patients received doxycycline 100 mg/d plus adapalene gel 0.1%. In both groups, from the sixth week, we started adapalene gel 0.1% as maintenance therapy until 12 weeks of follow-up. Primary end point was the reduction of acne lesions at the 6-week follow-up, which was evaluated by 2 investigators blinded to the intervention. Results The median percent reductions in noninflammatory lesion count (P = 0.013) and total lesions (P = 0.038) at 6 weeks was found to be significantly higher in the group receiving PDT. At 12 weeks there was a greater reduction of inflammatory lesions in PDT group with 84% vs. 74% for group who received doxycycline plus adapalene (P = 0.020) as well as in reducing total lesions with 79% vs. 67% respectively (P = 0.026). No severe side-effects were observed for either therapy. Conclusions ALA-PDT offers promise as an alternative treatment for moderately severe inflammatory acne that has a higher effectiveness than the combination of doxycycline and adapalene gel in reducing noninflammatory and total lesions at 6 weeks. There were significantly superior reductions at 12 weeks in the combination of PDT group followed by adapalene gel in total, inflammatory, and noninflammatory lesions.