Defining disease beyond conceptual analysis: An analysis of conceptual analysis in philosophy of medicine

摘要

Conceptual analysis of health and disease is portrayed as consisting in the confrontation of a set of criteria - a "definition" - with a set of cases, called instances of either "health" or "disease." Apart from logical counter-arguments, there is no other way to refute an opponent's definition than by providing counter-cases. As resorting to intensional stipulation (stipulation of meaning) is not forbidden, several contenders can therefore be deemed to have succeeded. This implies that conceptual analysis alone is not likely to decide between naturalism and normativism. An alternative to this approach would be to examine whether the concept of disease can be naturalized.