Neo-Marshettum Equilibrium versus Schumpeterian Creative Destruction: Its Impact on Business Research and Economic Policy

摘要

A cold war exists in faculties of business and economics. It is fought between the neo-Marshellians that advocate the elegant simplifying assumption of equilibrium and the Schumpe-terians that believe that economic growth is driven by the recognition of new opportunities and the capture of associated benefits through innovation. This fundamental disagreement is referred to as a cold war because the battles are fought indirectly with discussions of wealth transfer (instead of wealth creation), big firms versus small firms (instead of innovative firms versus noninnova-tive), and stability and managed earnings versus Sarbanes-Oxley and full disclosure. This note points out that this conflict does in fact exist and then provides a review of the literature and support for the Schumpeterian position as it relates to small business and associated economic policy. The literature is provided by one of the pioneers in this field, Professor Bruce Kirchhoff, as his last direct contribution to the field that he championed for decades.