Judging unions’ future using a historical perspective: the public policy choice between competition and unionization

摘要

VII. Conclusion In discussing the future of private sector union membership one needs to evaluate the early period of union ascendancy (1930s through the early 1950s) as well as the past few decades when unions have been in decline. We know trends currently in place are unfavorable to unions. What conditions would be favorable? When the earlier period of union growth us studied, two factors become prominent — the competitiveness of the labor market and the ability of unions to fullfill their major goal of either extracting economic rents or remedying market failures that result in exploitive employment relationship. I am grateful to Barry Hirsch, Bruce Kaufman, and Edward Rock for helpful comments and to Bonnie Clause and Greg Duffy for research assistance, and to J. William Draper for critical library support.