Comments and decision of the editor Prof. Dr. Michael Oehme from the environmental chemistry section of Chemosphere

摘要

I have handled the accusation of Prof. Karen Johannes-son, since I was not involved in the former review process of the manuscript and therefore independent. This severe accusation was sent to the responsible author of the manuscript published in Chemosphere, Dr. S.M. Ding, for a comment. Simultaneously, all points were checked by me in detail. Finally, the whole case was sent to the members of the editorial board and the co-editors of the environmental chemistry section for comments.