Is voice therapy an effective treatment for dysphonia? A randomised controlled trial

摘要

Objectives To assess the overall efficacy of voice therapy for dysphonia. Design Single blind randomised controlled trial. Setting Outpatient clinic in a teaching hospital. Participants 204 outpatients aged 17-87 with a primary symptom of persistent hoarseness for at least two months. Interventions After baseline assessments, patients were randomised to six weeks of either voice therapy or no treatment. Assessments were repeated at six weeks on the 145 (71%) patients who continued to this stage and at 12-14 weeks on the 133 (65%) patients who completed the study. The assessments at the three time points for the 70 patients who completed treatment and the 63 patients in the group given no treatment were compared. Main outcome measures Ratings of laryngeal features, Buffalo voice profile, amplitude and pitch perturbation, voice profile questionnaire, hospital anxiety and depression scale, clinical interview schedule, SF-36. Results Voice therapy improved voice quality as assessed by rating by patients (P = 0.001) and rating by observer (P < 0.001). The treatment effects for these two outcomes were 4.1 (95% confidence interval 1.7 to 6.6) points and 0.82 (0.50 to 1.13) points. Amplitude perturbation showed improvement at six weeks but not on completion of the study. Patients with dysphonia had appreciable psychological distress and lower quality of life than controls, but voice therapy had no significant impact on either of these variables. bConclusion Voice therapy is effective in improving voice quality as assessed by self rated and observer rated methods.