Dependence and independence of survival parameters on linear energy transfer in cells and tissues

摘要

Carbon-ion radiotherapy has been used to treat more than 9000 cancer patients in the world since 1994. Spreading of the Bragg peak is necessary for carbon-ion radiotherapy, and is designed based on the linear–quadratic model that is commonly used for photon therapy. Our recent analysis using in vitro cell kills and in vivo mouse tissue reaction indicates that radiation quality affects mainly the alpha terms, but much less the beta terms, which raises the question of whether this is true in other biological systems. Survival parameters alpha and beta for 45 in vitro mammalian cell lines were obtained by colony formation after irradiation with carbon ions, fast neutrons and X-rays. Relationships between survival parameters and linear energy transfer (LET) below 100 keV/μm were obtained for 4 mammalian cell lines. Mouse skin reaction and tumor growth delay were measured after fractionated irradiation. The Fe-plot provided survival parameters of the tissue reactions. A clear separation between X-rays and high-LET radiation was observed for alpha values, but not for beta values. Alpha values/terms increased with increasing LET in any cells and tissues studied, while beta did not show a systematic change. We have found a puzzle or contradiction in common interpretations of the linear-quadratic model that causes us to question whether the model is appropriate for interpreting biological effectiveness of high-LET radiation up to 500 keV/μm, probably because of inconsistency in the concept of damage interaction. A repair saturation model proposed here was good enough to fit cell kill efficiency by radiation of wide-ranged LET. A model incorporating damage complexity and repair saturation would be suitable for heavy-ion radiotherapy.