从俞平伯晚年自省和“李希凡自述”想到的（之三）--回应俞平伯晚年的红学研究反思

摘要

Yu Pingbo’ s introspection to redology in his later years is believable and should be given high at-tention.There is intrinsic causality between his great change on his redology and the criticism to him in 1954.We can not totally repudiate the criticism to Yu Pingbo and the comments on A Dream of Red Mnasions.Some present chaotic phenomena are flooding of the mistaken research idea and method that have been criticized at that time . This flooding has to do with the total repudiate.%俞平伯先生晚年的红学自省是真实可信的，应引起红学界高度重视，他的红学研究思想的重大变化同1954年那场对他的批评有内在的因果关系。对当年那场“批俞评红”不能全盘否定，不能只讲负面问题，全面否定其正确性和必要性。现在红学研究的一些乱象正是当年批判过了的错误研究思想、研究方法的泛滥。这种泛滥同对当年的全盘否定不无关系。