Penehyclidine Hydrochloride Premedication Is Not Associated with Increased Incidence of Post-Operative Cognitive Dysfunction or Delirium:A Systemic Review and Meta-Analysis

摘要

Objective Post-operative cognitive dysfunction(POCD)and post-operative delirium(POD)are two common post-operative cerebral complications.The current meta-analysis was to systematically review the effects of penehyclidine hydrochloride(PHC)on POCD and POD in surgical patients.Methods Electronic databases were searched to identify all randomized controlled trials comparing PHC with atropine/scopolamine/placebo on POCD and POD in surgical patients.Primary outcomes of interest included the incidences of POCD and POD;the secondary outcomes of interest included peri-operative minimental state examination(MMSE)scores.Two authors independently extracted peri-operative data,including patients'baseline characteristics,surgical variables,and outcome data.For dichotomous data(POCD and POD occurrence),treatment effects were calculated as odds ratio(OR)and 95%confidential interval(Cl).Each outcome was tested for heterogeneity,and randomized-effects or fixed-effects model was used in the presence or absence of significant heterogeneity.For continuous variables(MMSE scores),treatment effects were calculated as weighted mean difference(WMD)and 95%CI.Statistical significance was defined as P<0.05.Results Our search yielded 33 studies including 4017 patients.Meta-analysis showed that,the incidence of POCD in PHC group was comparable to that in saline group(OR=0.97;95%Ck 0.S8-1.64;P=0.92),scopolamine group(OR=0.78;95%CI:0.48-1.27;P=0.32)and atropine group(0R=1.20;95%Ch 0.86-1.67;P=0.29).The incidence of POD in PHC group was comparable to that in saline group(OR=1.53;95%CI:0.81-2.90;P=0.19)and scopolamine group(OR=0.53;95%CI:0.06-4.56;P=0.56),but higher than that in atropine group(OR=4.49;95%CI:1.34-15.01;P=0.01).Conclusions PHC premedication was not associated with increased incidences of POCD or POD as compared to either scopolamine or placebo.