Multicenter Performance Evaluation of the Simplexa Bordetella Direct Kit in Nasopharyngeal Swab Specimens

摘要

Detection of Bordetella pertussis and Bordetella parapertussis using molecular methods is sensitive and specific with a short turnaround time compared to other diagnostic methods. In this multicenter study, we compared the performance of the Simplexa Bordetella Direct kit to those of other molecular assays in detecting and differentiating B. pertussis and B. parapertussis in nasopharyngeal swab specimens. The limits of detection (LOD5) were 150 CFU/ml or 3 fg/mu l of DNA for B. pertussis and 1,500 CFU/mu l or 10 fg/mu l of DNA for B. parapertussis. A total of 1,103 fresh and residual frozen specimens from eight clinical sites were tested. Combining the data from individual clinical sites using different comparative assays, the overall positive percent agreement (PPA) and negative percent agreement (NPA) for B. pertussis were 98.7 and 97.3, respectively. The overall PPA and NPA for B. parapertussis were 96.7 and 100, respectively. For prospective fresh specimens, the overall PPA and NPA for both targets were 97.7 and 99.3, respectively. For retrospective frozen specimens, the overall PPA and NPA for both targets were 92.6 and 93.2, respectively. The percentage of invalid results was 1.0. A cross-reactivity study using 74 non-Bordetella bacterial species and five yeast species revealed that the Simplexa Bordetella Direct kit was 100 specific. The hands-on time and assay run time of the Simplexa Bordetella Direct kit are favorable compared to those of other commercial and laboratory-developed tests. In summary, the Simplexa Bordetella Direct kit has a performance comparable to those of other molecular assays for the detection of B. pertussis and B. parapertussis.