A Hypothesis Regarding the Poor Blue Constancy of CIELAB

摘要

The poor blue constancy of the CIELAB equations has been noted by a number of researchers, and various proposals have been made to address this shortcoming. The specific issue is the tendency for highly chromatic blues to appear more purple as the chroma is reduced for a constant hue angle. The root cause for the poor CIELAB blue constancy has been an open question, although one possibility is a basic deficiency in the CIELAB equations. An alternative hypothesis is that the equations, in combination with color matching functions with a distinct secondary lobe on the x-bar or long-wavelength sensitive channel, such as those found on the International Commission on Illumination (CIE) 1931 and 1964 Standard Observers, are problematic. The spectral curves of a constant hue IPT (Intensity, Protan, and Tritan) blue step ramp displayed on a CRT are used to explore this hypothesis. Additional discussion examines the use of sharpened sensors and achieving parallel tritanopic confusion lines in the CIELAB color space. The results suggest that use of the CIE Standard Observers with the CIELAB equations results in poor blue constancy and distorted tritanopic confusion lines.